PHVA vs Wing Assistant

Last updated

Dedicated VA vs Shared VA Model: Why Your VA's Full Attention Matters

Quick Comparison

Wing Assistant PHVA
Monthly Cost $899–1,499 $2,195–3,995
full-time, flat, all-inclusive
Service Model Managed placement + support Fully managed: payroll, PH compliance, dedicated Success Manager
VA Assignment Shared between multiple clients Dedicated to your business only
Time to Hire 1–2 weeks ~11 days (VA already certified)
VA Focus Divided attention (3-5 clients) 100% on your business
System Learning Curve Slower (learning multiple systems) Faster (one business, deep knowledge)
Success Manager Yes, shared with other clients Yes, dedicated to your relationship
Replacement Guarantee 30 days 30 days
Specialization General admin tasks Real estate, admin, support (trained)
Uptime/Availability Your VA might be offline if handling other clients Your VA is available during your hours

The Hidden Cost of Shared VAs: Divided Attention

Wing's monthly price sits below PHVA's, but with Wing you're sharing that VA with 3-5 other clients, while PHVA places one certified VA who works only for you. That difference matters more than most people realize.

What Happens with a Shared VA

  • Your VA works 8 hours a day. If they have 4 clients, that's about 2 hours per client
  • Context switching overhead. Your VA spends time jumping between your systems, another client's processes, and two more
  • Learning curve is shared. Your VA learns your CRM, your templates, your team—while also learning 3-4 other systems
  • Priorities conflict. If another client has an urgent task during your peak hours, your VA is unavailable
  • System expertise is diluted. They know your business "pretty well" vs deeply
  • Relationship is transactional. Your Success Manager also has multiple clients

Net result: You're paying for a full-time VA but getting part-time results.

What You Get with a Dedicated VA (PHVA)

  • Your VA works 40 hours a week focused entirely on you. No division of attention
  • Deep system expertise. They become an expert in your tools, workflows, and business
  • Faster onboarding. One business to learn means learning happens faster
  • No priority conflicts. You're always their priority
  • Genuine relationship. Your Success Manager knows your business deeply
  • Certified before you meet them. Every PHVA VA completes Academy certification (only ~2% of applicants are accepted) before you're introduced, and founder Julian Lundgren joins your kickoff call personally
  • Scaling is simple. When you need more help, you add another dedicated VA (not shared)

Net result: You're paying for a full-time VA and getting full-time results.

The Real Comparison: What Each Dollar Buys

Wing's sticker price is lower than PHVA's. But sticker price only tells part of the story. Here's what each model actually delivers.

Wing's Model (Shared VA)

PHVA's Model (Dedicated VA)

Wing costs less up front. PHVA costs more, and bundles in certification, full management, and a guarantee the shared model doesn't. When you divide by the hours of dedicated attention you actually receive, the gap narrows sharply.

Real World: How Shared VA Attention Gets Divided

Let's say you're a real estate team and you need your VA to manage lead follow-up, CRM updates, and social media posts.

Monday with a Shared VA (Wing)

Total time on your work: ~2.5 hours of focused time + 1 hour of context switching = 3.5 effective hours

Monday with a Dedicated VA (PHVA)

Total time on your work: 7-8 hours of focused, uninterrupted time

The difference: With PHVA, your VA accomplishes 2-3x more actual work because there's no attention division.

Specialization: General Admin vs Real Estate Focus

Both Wing and PHVA handle general admin. But PHVA specializes in real estate and trains accordingly.

Wing's Approach

PHVA Academy Approach

If you're in real estate, a PHVA VA with Academy training will be productive from day 3. A Wing shared VA will take 4-6 weeks to understand your industry.

Scaling: When You Need More Help

Scaling with Wing

Wing's shared model means adding more capacity is awkward. You'd either:

Scaling with PHVA

Adding a second dedicated VA is simple. Your first VA trains your second. Both focus 100% on your business.

Bottom line: PHVA's model scales. Wing's shared model doesn't scale as cleanly.

Who Should Choose Wing

Wing isn't bad; it's just a different model with trade-offs.

Who Should Choose PHVA

PHVA is the choice if you want a certified, dedicated VA's full attention as a fully managed service: $2,195–3,995/month, full-time, everything included.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does PHVA ever use shared VA models?

No. We believe dedicated VAs deliver better results, and we place full-time VAs (40 hrs/week) only. If you're looking for part-time or fractional support (5-10 hours/week), a shared service like Wing may fit better. For full-time support, we don't do shared models.

What if I only need part-time help?

PHVA places full-time VAs (40 hrs/week) only. If you truly need just a few hours a week, Wing's shared model may suit you better. But most businesses underestimate their needs. A role that starts light is usually full within a few months, and with PHVA you get a dedicated VA whose full attention is on you.

Can my PHVA VA work on multiple client projects for me?

Yes! Your VA works exclusively for you, so they can manage multiple projects within your business. Real estate team managing 3 branches? Your VA can handle all of them. They just don't split time with other clients.

What's the learning curve for onboarding?

PHVA VAs are Academy-trained, so core skills are there. Learning your systems takes 3-5 days. Wing's VAs might take 2-4 weeks because they're learning your industry plus your specific systems. Dedicated attention means faster productivity.

How do I know if shared vs dedicated is right for me?

Ask yourself: "Do I want my VA's full attention, or am I comfortable sharing?" If you said "full attention," PHVA is the answer. Most founders choose dedicated models once they understand the difference.

Your VA's Attention Matters

A dedicated, certified VA outperforms a shared one. PHVA gives you 100% focus, real-estate specialization, full management, and a Success Manager committed to your success: $2,195–3,995/month, full-time, with everything included.

Let's talk about whether a dedicated model is right for you.